Here’s something I keep seeing on title commitments lately.
A homeowner calls a listing agent. Nice house. Decent equity, at least on paper. Then the title work comes back with a second lien nobody mentioned. It’s recorded to the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development. Zero interest. Due in full at closing.
Nobody hid it. Most of the time the homeowner simply forgot it was there.
That lien is an FHA partial claim. And the rules around it have changed in a way every Realtor and loan officer needs to understand, because it’s going to shape the listing pipeline for the next year or more.
What The Wall Street Journal Laid Out
This spring, Carol Ryan at The Wall Street Journal wrote a sharp piece on what happens now that the government has pulled back on one of the biggest foreclosure prevention tools of the pandemic era. Her headline didn’t sugarcoat it: the help is ending, and foreclosures are expected to follow.
The early numbers she cited point the same direction. Foreclosure filings in March were up 28% from a year earlier, according to Attom. Still below 2019 levels. But climbing.
Partial Claims in Plain English
When an FHA borrower falls behind, HUD can pay the missed amount and bring the loan current. That money doesn’t disappear. It becomes a separate junior lien on the home. No monthly payment. No interest. It just waits quietly until the home is sold, refinanced, or the first mortgage is paid off.
Think of it like a pause button with a receipt attached.
During the pandemic, HUD removed the limit on how many times a borrower could use it. The only real ceiling was that total claims couldn’t go above 30% of the loan balance. For families in genuine hardship, that was a lifeline. The Journal also found borrowers who went back to the well again and again. One Massachusetts homeowner stacked up five partial claims worth $96,000 since 2021. Interest free, for the life of the loan.
What Changed
Starting last October, the guardrails went back up. Under the tighter rules described in the article:
- Borrowers can use a partial claim or loan modification only once every two years.
- They have to make three consecutive mortgage payments before they qualify for help clearing the arrears.
The goal makes sense. Help should go to people who can actually sustain the payment. But the side effect is real too. Borrowers who can’t string together those three payments now have fewer places to land.
Why This Matters More Than the Percentages Suggest
FHA loans are only about one in ten mortgages nationwide. So no, this isn’t 2008.
But FHA is where first-time buyers, young families, and moderate income households live. In a military town like Clarksville and Fort Campbell, FHA and VA loans are a big part of what we do every single day.
John Comiskey of Reverse Engineering Finance tracks most of the FHA loans inside Ginnie Mae securities. By his count, 11.6% of those borrowers were delinquent as of March. Based on his conversations with loan servicers, he estimates up to half of the seriously delinquent borrowers may not be able to qualify under the new rules. If that happens, roughly 250,000 people could lose their homes over 12 to 18 months, through a sale, a short sale, or a foreclosure.
His way of putting it stuck with me: “The flood behind the dam has to be released.”
Slow down on that for a second. These aren’t new problems. They’re old problems that were on pause. And pauses end.
The Deeper Principle: Equity Decides the Ending
This is the part I want every agent to hear.
Two homeowners can be in the exact same financial trouble and walk away with completely different outcomes. The difference is equity.
Remember that Massachusetts homeowner? Once you add the partial claims, the home has more than $500,000 owed against it. But that local market is hot, and one industry expert estimates it could sell for around $625,000. That’s a homeowner who can sell, pay off everything, and still walk away with something.
Now picture a newer home in Lee County, Florida, bought from the builder in 2022 for $394,000. It went through foreclosure and is now listed at $270,000, while a similar home nearby sold this year for $376,000. That owner lost the house. The neighbors may lose some value too.
Same storm. Different roof.
Here’s what that means for you. A homeowner with equity who acts early has options. A homeowner who waits for the foreclosure notice usually doesn’t. The window between “I’m behind” and “it’s too late” is exactly where a good Realtor and a good loan officer can change a family’s whole story.
Your Playbook for the Next 18 Months
For Realtors
- Check for silent liens before you list. A partial claim shows up in public records as a second mortgage in favor of HUD. Find it at the listing appointment, not at the closing table.
- Have the equity conversation with kindness. Some homeowners have no idea a sale could pay off everything and leave money in their pocket. Show them the math.
- Point them to help first. Their servicer and a HUD-approved housing counselor belong in the conversation. Sometimes keeping the home is the right answer. Our job is clarity, not pressure.
- Watch your comps. Distressed sales can pull down values in softer neighborhoods. Price with that in mind and be ready to explain why.
For Loan Officers
- Know your FHA past clients. If they used forbearance during COVID, they may have a partial claim. Make sure they know it exists before it surprises them.
- Build the partial claim payoff into every refinance and sale conversation, so the net numbers are real from day one.
- Bring your Realtor partners in early. The sooner a listing agent knows about a homeowner who is struggling but has equity, the more options everyone has.
The Bottom Line
Rules change. Programs come and go. People don’t.
The families behind these numbers aren’t statistics. They’re neighbors, soldiers, teachers, and first-time buyers who did their best through a hard few years. Many of them have more options than they realize. They just need someone to explain it clearly before the clock runs out.
So here’s my challenge. Pick five past FHA clients or sphere contacts this week. Pull the public record. See if there’s a partial claim lien. If there is, start a conversation. Not a pitch. A check-in.
That’s how trust gets built. And trust is still the greatest competitive advantage.
Want a free COVID era lien check on a property before you list it? Call or text me at (931) 980-9764 or email Kate@VanDykMortgage.com.
Knowledge is power.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is an FHA partial claim?
It’s a tool HUD uses to help FHA borrowers who fall behind. HUD pays the past-due amount to bring the loan current, and that amount becomes a separate junior lien on the home.
2. Does a partial claim have to be paid back?
Yes. It carries no interest and no monthly payment, but it comes due when the home is sold, refinanced, or the first mortgage is paid off or reaches maturity.
3. How can I tell if a homeowner has a partial claim lien?
Look in the recorded documents for a second mortgage in favor of the Secretary of Housing and Urban Development, or ask your title company to check before you list. The homeowner may also have paperwork from their servicer.
4. What changed in the partial claim rules?
Under the tighter rules that began last October, borrowers can use a partial claim or loan modification only once every two years, and they need to make three consecutive mortgage payments before they qualify for help with arrears.
5. Why should Realtors care about this?
Because these liens surprise sellers at the closing table, and because some homeowners who can no longer get help may need to sell. An agent who understands partial claims can protect today’s closings and earn tomorrow’s listings.
6. Will this cause home prices to crash?
Not nationally. FHA loans are only about one in ten mortgages. The bigger risk is local, in neighborhoods where prices are already soft and distressed sales can drag down comparable values.
7. What is “accidental equity”?
It’s equity a homeowner built mostly because local prices rose, not because they paid the loan down. In strong markets, that equity can let a struggling owner sell and pay off everything, including the partial claim.
8. Can a homeowner who is behind on payments still sell?
Often, yes. If the sale price covers the first mortgage, the partial claim, and closing costs, a regular sale is usually possible. If not, a short sale may be an option. Talk with the servicer early.
9. What should a homeowner who is behind do first?
Call the loan servicer right away and connect with a HUD-approved housing counselor. You can find one through HUD at 800-569-4287. Acting early keeps the most options open.
10. How can The Deal Doctor help?
I offer Realtors a free COVID era lien check on a property before it lists, plus payoff and net sheet math so sellers know where they stand. Call or text (931) 980-9764 or email Kate@VanDykMortgage.com.
Source and inspiration: Carol Ryan, “A Federal Housing Handout Has Ended. Foreclosures Will Follow,” The Wall Street Journal, May 3, 2026 (print edition May 4, 2026, as “As Handouts End, Foreclosures Follow”). Foreclosure data from Attom and FHA delinquency data from Reverse Engineering Finance as reported in that article. The commentary and playbook are mine.
Kate Deiboldt, Senior Mortgage Advisor, NMLS #18487. VanDyk Mortgage Corporation, Company NMLS #3035, 2515 Wilma Rudolph Blvd Ste 102 & 103, Clarksville, TN 37040. Licensed in TN, KY, AL, FL, GA, TX, and IL. Verify licensing at http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org. Equal Housing Lender. This article is for educational purposes only and is not legal or tax advice, a commitment to lend, or an offer of credit. All loans are subject to credit approval, underwriting guidelines, and property eligibility. Programs, rates, and terms are subject to change without notice. Not all applicants will qualify.

Leave a Reply