Every few months, a headline lands that makes your phone ring. This week it was Peter Schiff.
In a recent Benzinga piece published on Yahoo Finance, Schiff pointed to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac shares dropping more than 20% in three trading days and called the housing market a disaster waiting to happen. His prediction? Home prices will implode.
That is a scary word. And your buyers read it too. So let’s slow down and talk about what is actually happening, what isn’t, and how you can turn a fear headline into a strategy conversation.
What Schiff Is Actually Worried About
Strip away the drama and his argument is pretty simple. Sellers don’t want to cut prices. Buyers can’t qualify at rates north of 7%. Inventory is building. Something has to give.
He also raised a bigger concern. If prices fall far enough, some owners could end up owing more than their homes are worth, and he believes some of them might walk away even with a 3% or 4% fixed rate in hand.
Here is the part worth noticing. The standoff he describes is real. Most of us are living it every day. Where I disagree is the leap from “stuck market” to “collapse.”
What the Numbers Are Really Saying
The same article shared some numbers you should know cold, because your clients will ask.
- About 14.5% of September purchase agreements fell through, a record for that month.
- Pending home sales slipped about 4% from the month before.
- Mortgage rates climbed back above 7% at the end of September.
Those are real warning lights. But look at what they measure. Cancellations. Fewer contracts. Higher payments. They describe a market where deals are harder to hold together. They do not, on their own, describe prices in freefall.
Leo Pareja, CEO of eXp Realty, put it well in the piece. He sees a softer market with fewer transactions, not a broad price collapse, and he pushed back hard on the Great Recession comparison. He also made the point every local agent already knows. Housing isn’t one market. It’s thousands of them.
Fewer transactions and falling prices are two very different stories. One means you have to work harder for every closing. The other means equity disappears. Right now, the evidence points much more toward the first.
Why This Isn’t 2008
I have been doing this for 26 years. I originated loans through 2008. I remember what that felt like, and this is not it.
Back then, the problem was the loans themselves. Stated income. No documentation. Payments that reset into something people could never afford. When values dipped, a lot of owners had nothing holding them in place.
Today’s homeowners mostly look different. Income is documented. Ability to repay is verified. A huge share of owners locked low fixed rates and have built real equity. That combination is exactly why sellers are holding out. They aren’t desperate. They are comfortable.
Can prices soften in some markets? Absolutely. Some already have. Can a homeowner with a 3% rate and a cushion of equity walk away? It’s possible, but it’s not the same pressure that broke the market last time. A soft patch and a crash are not the same diagnosis.
The Real Problem: Price Expectations vs. Payment Reality
Here is what I see in my files every week. A buyer loves a house. The price is fine. The payment isn’t. Meanwhile, the seller is anchored to a number from two years ago.
That gap is where listings go stale. It’s where deals fall apart in week three. And it’s the gap that headline writers call a crisis.
I call it a negotiation problem. And negotiation problems have solutions.
Think about it like a doctor looking at symptoms. A cough can mean a cold or something serious. You don’t panic. You run the tests, look at the whole patient, and treat what’s actually there.
How to Talk to a Nervous Client
When a buyer sends you that article, don’t argue with it. Get curious with them.
- Acknowledge it. “I saw that too. It’s a fair question.”
- Separate the national from the local. Pull what is actually happening on their street, in their price range.
- Bring it back to the payment. Nobody lives in a national average. They live in a monthly payment.
- Talk timeline. If they plan to stay seven to ten years, a short-term dip matters a lot less than buying a home they can comfortably afford.
For sellers, the conversation flips. If buyers are scared and rates are high, the seller who solves the payment problem wins. Not always with a lower price. Often with a smarter structure.
The Strategy Tools That Actually Move Deals
This is where a lender partner earns their keep.
- Seller credits toward a buydown. A seller credit used to buy down the rate can lower the buyer’s payment more than the same dollars taken off the price.
- Smart rate lock timing. In a market this jumpy, knowing when to lock and when a float-down option makes sense protects your buyer from a surprise at closing.
- Program fit. VA, FHA, and down payment assistance can change the math in ways a buyer never expected.
- Listing payment analysis. Showing buyers the payment options on a listing, not just the price, gives a stale listing a second life.
Headlines sell fear. Strategy closes deals.
Your Next Move
Markets change. Rates change. People don’t. Your clients still want a home, a plan, and someone they trust to tell them the truth.
So this week, pick one listing that has been sitting or one buyer who has gone quiet. Run the payment strategies before you run the price cut. If you want a second set of eyes, send it my way and I’ll put together a Deal Doctor analysis.
Knowledge is power. Let’s use it.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Are home prices going to crash?
Nobody can promise what prices will do, but the current data points more toward fewer sales and softer pricing in some areas than a nationwide collapse. Local conditions matter far more than national predictions.
2. Who is Peter Schiff?
Schiff is an economist and investment commentator known for bearish market calls. His views are worth hearing, but they are one perspective, not a forecast set in stone.
3. Why does a drop in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac stock matter?
Their share prices reflect investor sentiment about housing finance. A sharp drop gets attention, but stock moves are not the same as home values falling in your neighborhood.
4. Why are so many purchase contracts falling through?
Higher rates, tighter budgets, inspection surprises, and buyer nerves all play a role. Many cancellations can be prevented with a solid preapproval and payment planning up front.
5. How is today’s market different from 2008?
Lending standards now require documented income and verified ability to repay, and many owners hold low fixed rates with meaningful equity. That is a very different foundation than the risky loans of the mid 2000s.
6. Should my buyers wait for prices to drop?
Trying to time the market is tough. A better question is whether the payment fits their budget today and whether they plan to stay long enough to ride out normal ups and downs.
7. What is a seller-paid buydown?
It’s when the seller contributes funds to lower the buyer’s interest rate, either temporarily or for the life of the loan. It can reduce the monthly payment more than an equal price reduction.
8. When should a buyer lock their rate?
It depends on the closing timeline, the buyer’s budget, and market movement. Talk with your loan officer about lock periods and whether a float-down option is available.
9. How can I help a stale listing sell?
Show buyers what the home costs per month, not just the price. Payment options like seller credits or buydowns often bring buyers back to listings they had passed over.
10. What should I say when a client sends me a scary headline?
Acknowledge the concern, compare national news to local data, and bring the conversation back to their payment and goals. Calm, clear facts build more trust than arguing with the headline.
Source: “Peter Schiff Sees ‘Disaster Waiting To Happen’” by Benzinga, published on Yahoo Finance, October 17, 2026.
Kate Deiboldt, Sr. Mortgage Advisor, NMLS #18487 | VanDyk Mortgage Corporation, NMLS #3035 | (931) 980-9764 | Kate@VanDykMortgage.com | http://www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org | Equal Housing Lender. This content is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend. All loans subject to credit approval, underwriting guidelines, and property eligibility. Rates, terms, and programs are subject to change without notice. Not all applicants will qualify.
Leave a Reply