Picture the school pickup line in a quiet suburb outside Kansas City. One dad pulls up in a Porsche. A few of the other parents have quietly stopped talking to him.
That is not a story about a car. It is a story about a mortgage rate.
The Wall Street Journal just profiled what it calls America’s “three percenters” in They’re Lucky Enough to Have a 3% Mortgage, and Feel Like They Can Never Move by Rebecca Picciotto (November 15, 2026). These are the roughly one in five mortgage holders who locked in a rate at or below 3% during the pandemic years. With the 30-year fixed sitting around 7.1% according to the article, their payments look like they came from a different planet.
I read it twice. Then I read it a third time with a highlighter. Because every person in that piece is someone a Realtor or loan officer should be talking to right now. And most of them aren’t hearing from anyone.
Five People, One Feeling
The Journal introduces five homeowners. Here is the short version.
The Porsche driver. Andrew Radcliff refinanced at 2.82% in 2019 and pays about $1,800 a month. With three kids and three dogs, he would love a bigger house. At today’s rates his payment would more than double, so he is adding on to the house he has instead.
The involuntary landlord. Alex Taylor inherited her mother’s home in a nicer area and moved there. She kept her 2.88% house as a rental rather than give up the rate. She doesn’t enjoy being a landlord, and she described that rate as “like one of those sticky rat traps.”
The never-renter. Laura Allison bought her Altoona, Pennsylvania home for $74,000 at 2.74%, the day before she turned 25. Her mortgage, taxes and insurance run about $510 a month. She plans to stay forever, while her brother has been house hunting for months without success.
The Zillow dreamer. Kenneth Tang, a software engineer near Seattle with a 2.75% rate, now caps his real estate browsing at about 30 minutes a week. He knows the math of a move, and he doesn’t want to fall in love with a house he won’t buy.
The early retiree. Eric Miller refinanced at 2.88% and retired at 41. He told the Journal that at today’s rates he would still be working his corporate job.
Different lives. Same feeling. They are holding something valuable, and they are afraid to set it down.
Why This Matters More Than the Headline
Here is what jumps off the page for me. These folks are not staying put because they love their houses. They are staying put because the math feels scary.
Look underneath. Radcliff wants more room. Taylor wanted out of landlording. Tang is still browsing listings, just on a timer. Those are not people who are done with real estate. Those are people who are waiting.
And that is the deeper principle. A rate can freeze a decision. It can’t freeze a life.
Kids grow. Parents age. Jobs move. Inheritances happen, just like Taylor’s did. The need keeps building quietly in the background. The rate only delays the conversation. Whoever is there, with clear numbers and a calm voice, when the need finally outweighs the rate is the person who gets that business.
Taylor said something else worth sitting with. Two people can live in identical houses, and the difference between them comes down to a few months of timing. That is how most homeowners experience this market. Like luck. A lottery. Our job is to turn luck into strategy.
Rate Math vs. Life Math
Most three percenters run one comparison: their rate against today’s rate. That comparison wins for staying every single time.
But it is the wrong comparison.
The better question is life math. What does the next five years look like in this house compared to that one? What is the renovation going to cost? What is the landlord stress costing? What about the commute, the bedrooms, the school district, the aging parent two states away?
Tang ran his numbers. Today about 13% of his income goes to housing. A move could push him closer to a quarter of it. That is real, and for him staying may be exactly the right call.
Our job is not to talk anyone out of a great rate. Our job is to make sure the decision is a decision, not a reflex.
Five Conversations to Start This Month
1. Keep it and buy the next one. For some homeowners, the low-rate house becomes a rental and they buy the next home. Run the numbers honestly, including vacancy, repairs and property management. Taylor’s rent covers her costs, and she still hates the job. In our Fort Campbell market, some veterans may have remaining VA entitlement that makes a second purchase possible while keeping the first home, depending on their entitlement and qualifying.
2. Tap equity without touching the first mortgage. Radcliff chose to renovate instead of move. A home equity line or a fixed second mortgage can fund that kind of project while the 3% first mortgage stays right where it is. Show the blended cost, not just the second loan’s rate.
3. Sell the rate, not just the house. FHA and VA loans can be assumable, with lender approval and a qualified buyer. In a military market like Clarksville, a seller with a 2-point-something VA loan may be holding a listing feature worth more than new countertops. I unpacked this in Golden Handcuffs, Not a Trap. Veteran sellers should understand how an assumption affects their entitlement before they agree to one.
4. Talk to the dreamers. Tang still looks at listings every week. So do a lot of your past clients. Saved searches, open house sign-ins and favorited homes are signals. Don’t pressure. Offer a payment strategy review that compares options side by side, including seller credits and buydowns.
5. Find the stuck renters in their circle. Allison’s brother has been searching for months. Nearly every three percenter knows a sibling, a grown child or a coworker who is stuck renting. Down payment assistance, FHA and VA programs can open doors that feel shut.
The Deal Doctor’s Take
People don’t buy rates. They buy the life the payment allows.
The three percenters are not a frozen market. They are a patient one. And patient people reward the professional who taught them something before asking for anything.
Technology changes. Markets change. Interest rates change. People don’t. Knowledge is power, and trust is still the greatest competitive advantage.
Here is your challenge for this week. Pull five past clients who closed or refinanced between 2020 and 2021. Don’t call to ask if they want to sell. Call to ask how the house is fitting their life right now. Then listen. The next move is usually hiding in the answer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a “three percenter”?
It is the nickname the Wall Street Journal gave homeowners who locked in a mortgage rate at or below 3%, mostly during the pandemic years when rates hit historic lows.
How many homeowners have a rate at or below 3%?
According to the Journal, about one in five mortgage holders falls into that group. That is a big slice of potential sellers and buyers who are currently sitting still.
Why don’t homeowners with low rates want to move?
Because replacing a sub-3% loan at today’s rates can more than double the payment on a similar loan amount. The rate becomes something they feel they would lose, so many delay moving even when the house no longer fits.
Is it ever smart to give up a 3% mortgage?
It can be. Life changes like a growing family, a job relocation, caring for a parent or downsizing can outweigh the payment difference. The key is comparing total life costs and goals, not just two interest rates.
Can I keep my low-rate home as a rental and buy another home?
Often, yes, if you qualify. Lenders look at income, reserves, any projected rental income and occupancy rules for the new home. Talk with a tax professional about rental property, and be honest about whether you want to be a landlord.
What is an assumable mortgage?
It is a loan a qualified buyer can take over, keeping the seller’s rate and remaining term. FHA and VA loans can be assumable with lender approval. The buyer usually needs to cover the difference between the price and the remaining loan balance.
Can I renovate without refinancing my low-rate loan?
Yes. A home equity line of credit or a fixed-rate second mortgage can fund improvements while your first mortgage stays untouched. Compare the blended cost of both loans to the cost of moving.
How can Realtors find opportunities with low-rate homeowners?
Start with past clients and sphere contacts who bought or refinanced in 2020 and 2021. Ask how the home is working for their life, and offer a side-by-side review of options like keep-and-rent, assumption or renovation.
What should loan officers say to past clients with low rates?
Lead with education, not a pitch. Congratulate them on a great rate, then offer to run life math: what staying, renovating, renting or moving would actually cost over the next few years.
Where do I start if I want to run my own numbers?
Reach out. I’m happy to build a no-pressure payment comparison so you can see your options clearly and decide on your own timeline.
Source: Rebecca Picciotto, “They’re Lucky Enough to Have a 3% Mortgage, and Feel Like They Can Never Move,” The Wall Street Journal, November 15, 2026. Homeowner details and figures above are as reported in that article. Commentary and strategies are my own.
Kate Deiboldt
Senior Mortgage Advisor, VanDyk Mortgage Corporation
NMLS #18487 | Company NMLS #3035
Kate@VanDykMortgage.com | (931) 980-9764
www.justcallkate.info | Facebook: @katematties
Licensed in TN, KY, AL, FL, GA, TX and IL
This article is for educational purposes only and is not a commitment to lend or an offer of credit. All loans are subject to credit approval, underwriting guidelines and property eligibility. Rates, terms and programs are subject to change without notice. Loan assumptions require lender approval and buyer qualification; VA entitlement rules vary by borrower. Consult a tax professional regarding rental property. Kate Deiboldt, NMLS #18487. VanDyk Mortgage Corporation, Company NMLS #3035. Verify licensing at www.nmlsconsumeraccess.org. Equal Housing Lender.

Leave a Reply