FHA, VA, USDA, and Conventional: A Side-by-Side Comparison for First-Time Buyers in Clarksville TN
FHA, VA, USDA, and conventional loans are the four primary mortgage programs for first-time buyers in Clarksville, Tennessee — each with different down payment requirements, cost structures, and eligibility rules. Choosing the wrong one costs money every month. This guide breaks down all four with 2026 numbers so you walk into pre-approval already knowing which loan fits.
The 2026 FHA loan limit floor is $541,287, per Neighbors Bank (2026), while the conforming loan limit is $832,750, per Freddie Mac (2025). In Montgomery County, those ceilings cover the vast majority of homes near Fort Campbell and in Clarksville’s fast-growing suburbs.
TL;DR — Key Takeaways
- VA loan = best deal for eligible military buyers — zero down, no monthly PMI, and the 2.15% funding fee is often cheaper long-term than FHA MIP.
- USDA loans cover parts of Montgomery County TN but not Clarksville’s city limits.
- THDA Great Choice Plus can stack on top of an FHA loan, covering up to $6,000 (deferred) or 5% of purchase price (up to $15,000) in DPA.
- Conventional beats FHA once your credit score hits 740+ and you can put 10–20% down.
- 2026 FHA limit for Montgomery County: $541,287; conforming limit: $832,750.
- Credit score minimums: VA has no official minimum (lenders use 580–620), FHA goes to 580, USDA requires ~640, conventional ~620+.
What Are These Four Loan Programs?
An FHA loan is a government-backed mortgage insured by the Federal Housing Administration, requiring as little as 3.5% down with a 580 credit score. A VA loan is a zero-down mortgage guaranteed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, available exclusively to eligible service members, veterans, and surviving spouses. A USDA loan is a no-down-payment mortgage backed by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, restricted to eligible rural and suburban areas. A conventional loan is a mortgage conforming to Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac guidelines with no government guarantee.
The Big Comparison: FHA vs VA vs USDA vs Conventional (2026)
| Feature | FHA | VA | USDA | Conventional |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Down Payment | 3.5% (580+ credit); 10% (500–579) | 0% | 0% | 3%–20%+ |
| Minimum Credit Score | 500 (FHA); lenders often require 580+ | No official minimum; lenders 580–620 | 640 | 620 minimum; best rates at 740+ |
| Mortgage Insurance / Fee | 1.75% upfront MIP + 0.55% annual MIP | 2.15% one-time funding fee; no monthly PMI | 1.0% upfront + 0.35% annual fee | PMI if <20% down; cancellable at 80% LTV |
| 2026 Loan Limit (Montgomery County TN) | $541,287 | No limit (full entitlement) | No set limit | $832,750 |
| DTI Flexibility | Up to 57% with compensating factors | No official cap; residual income test | Up to 41%+ | Up to 45–50% with DU/LP |
| Eligibility | Any U.S. borrower meeting credit/income standards | Veterans, active-duty, surviving spouses; COE required | Income ≤$119,850 (1–4 persons); rural/suburban area required | Any borrower meeting Fannie/Freddie guidelines |
| Best For… | Buyers with fair credit or limited savings; THDA stackable | Fort Campbell military buyers; best overall value for eligible Veterans | Buyers in rural/suburban Montgomery County TN | Buyers with 740+ credit, larger down payment, or investment property |
How to Choose the Right Loan in 6 Steps
- Check VA eligibility first. If you are active duty, a veteran, or a surviving spouse connected to Fort Campbell, request your Certificate of Eligibility (COE) through VA.gov before comparing anything else.
- Check the USDA eligibility map. If the home is outside Clarksville’s city limits — in rural or suburban Montgomery County — it may qualify. Use the USDA eligibility portal to verify the address.
- Pull your credit score. A 580 score opens FHA with 3.5% down. A 640 score unlocks USDA and THDA’s Great Choice program. A 740+ score is where conventional starts beating FHA on total cost.
- Calculate your total cash available for closing. THDA Great Choice Plus can cover up to $6,000 (deferred, 0% interest) or up to $15,000 for first-time homebuyers in Tennessee. VA and USDA close with zero down.
- Run the long-term MIP/PMI cost comparison. FHA MIP at 0.55% does not cancel on sub-10% down loans. The VA’s 2.15% funding fee is one-time with no monthly insurance. Conventional PMI cancels at 80% LTV.
- Match the loan to the property and your exit strategy. Renovation project? FHA 203(k) is an option. Investment property or second home? Only conventional qualifies.
FAQ — FHA, VA, USDA & Conventional Loans for Clarksville TN Buyers
Which loan program is cheapest long-term?
For eligible Veterans and service members, the VA loan is almost always cheapest. The 2.15% one-time funding fee is a sunk cost, but with zero monthly PMI versus FHA’s 0.55% annual MIP, a VA borrower on a $350,000 loan saves roughly $160/month in insurance alone. USDA is the runner-up for qualifying borrowers.
Do USDA loans cover Clarksville’s city limits?
No. Clarksville, Tennessee — with over 180,000 residents — does not qualify as a USDA rural area. However, addresses in the surrounding rural and suburban portions of Montgomery County TN, outside the city limits, may be eligible. You must verify each specific address on the USDA eligibility map.
Can THDA Great Choice Plus stack with an FHA loan?
Yes. THDA’s Great Choice Home Loan wraps around an FHA (or USDA or VA) first mortgage. The Great Choice Plus second loan provides either $6,000 in deferred, 0%-interest DPA or up to $15,000 (5% of purchase price), per THDA (2026). Requirements: 640 minimum credit score and completion of a THDA-approved homebuyer education course.
When does a conventional loan beat FHA for a first-time buyer?
Conventional wins when: (1) credit score is 740+, where PMI rates drop vs. FHA’s fixed 0.55% MIP; (2) you put 10–20% down, since conventional PMI cancels at 80% LTV while FHA MIP on a sub-10% down loan runs the full 30-year term; or (3) buying a non-owner-occupied property.
What credit score do you need for a VA loan?
The VA itself sets no minimum credit score. In practice, lenders serving Fort Campbell VA loan applicants typically require 580–620 minimum. Borrowers with scores of 700+ see the best rates.
Written by Kate Matties-Deiboldt at The Blue Note Home — NMLS #18487, VanDyk Mortgage. Kate is a Clarksville TN mortgage lender and Fort Campbell VA loan specialist serving Montgomery County, Clarksville, Fort Campbell, Nashville, and Middle Tennessee.
Leave a Reply