Have you noticed it yet?
You walk into a listing appointment, and the seller is quoting the house down the street that sold in 2021. Then you sit down with a buyer that same afternoon, and they’re staring at a monthly payment that makes their stomach drop.
Same town. Sometimes the same street. Two completely different markets.
Here’s how I explain it.
Sellers remember the price environment created by cheap money. Buyers live in the payment environment created by expensive money.
And the correction happens when those two realities finally meet.
Let me be clear about something. That’s not a crash prediction. It’s a description of the conversation happening at kitchen tables all over the country right now. The gap is real. And the professionals who learn to bridge it are going to have a very good few years.
Two People, Two Calendars
Think about it from the seller’s side. They watched their home value climb for years. Neighbors bragged at cookouts. Their home value app sent them happy little emails. Their number is anchored to a time when a buyer could borrow at around 3%.
Now think about the buyer. They don’t care what the house was worth in 2021. They care what it costs on the first of the month. Today.
Let me put real math behind that. A $350,000 loan at 3% is about $1,476 a month in principal and interest. That same loan at 6.5% is about $2,212. That’s $736 more every single month. Same house. Same street. Same kitchen.
Now flip it around. If a buyer can comfortably handle that $1,476 payment, at 6.5% it only supports a loan of about $233,500.
(These are illustrative numbers for principal and interest only. They are not a rate quote.)
So when a seller says, “But the house is worth what it’s worth,” they’re not wrong about the past. They’re just living on a calendar the buyer doesn’t share.
It’s a little like gas prices. Most of us still remember paying under two dollars a gallon. That memory doesn’t change what the pump says today. It just makes paying it feel worse. Sellers aren’t wrong for remembering. They just can’t sell to the 2021 buyer, because that buyer isn’t coming back.
Why This Matters to Us
Listings rarely stall because people are stubborn. They stall because people are confused.
The seller isn’t greedy. The buyer isn’t cheap. They’re both reacting honestly to the information they have. When nobody translates between the two, homes sit, price reductions stack up, and everybody gets frustrated. Including us.
I’ve sat in listing appointments where the room got tense the second price came up. And I’ve watched that same room relax when we stopped arguing about what the house is worth and started talking about what a buyer can actually pay. The facts didn’t change. The framing did.
The deeper principle is simple.
Price is a number. Payment is a feeling.
Sellers negotiate on price. Buyers decide on payment. Our job is to connect those two languages before frustration does it for us.
That’s where realtors and loan officers become the most valuable people in the transaction. Not as salespeople. As translators.
How Realtors Can Lead the Conversation
Bring payment math into the listing appointment. Don’t just show comps. Show what a typical buyer’s monthly payment looks like at today’s rates for that list price. When a seller sees that pricing $25,000 above the market adds roughly $158 a month to every buyer’s payment, something clicks. Bring your loan officer into this. It takes us about ten minutes.
Reframe the seller’s win. Many sellers are also buyers. If they’re moving up, the same market that feels soft on the sale side may work in their favor on the purchase side. Help them see the whole picture, not just one number.
Talk concessions before price cuts. A seller credit toward a rate buydown can often do more for a buyer’s monthly payment than the same dollars taken off the price. The seller protects their number on paper. The buyer gets a payment they can live with. Everybody keeps their dignity, and that matters more than we admit.
Price for the market you’re actually in. The first two weeks on the market are your loudest. A home priced to today’s payment reality gets showings. A home priced to 2021’s memory gets feedback.
How Loan Officers Can Lead the Conversation
Start with the payment, not the rate. Buyers hear “six-and-a-half percent” and panic. Show them the whole monthly picture and what it means for their budget. Then show them the levers they can pull.
Know your tools cold. Temporary buydowns. Permanent buydowns. Seller concessions. Down payment assistance. FHA and VA options. Assumable loans. For my military families here around Fort Campbell, assuming a seller’s existing VA loan with a lower rate can be a genuine game changer when the buyer qualifies and the numbers work. Every one of these tools closes part of the gap between seller memory and buyer reality.
Be the realtor’s partner on listing strategy. Offer to build a simple payment sheet for every listing. Buyers shop payments on their phones at 10 o’clock at night. Give them the answer before they have to ask.
Be honest about refinancing. “Marry the house, date the rate” became a cliche because it’s only half true. Rates may come down. They may not. Never sell a buyer on a refinance that isn’t guaranteed. Sell them on a payment they can afford today. If rates drop later, that’s a bonus. It’s not a business plan.
The Correction Is a Conversation
When people hear the word “correction,” they picture prices crashing. That’s not what I see.
I see thousands of individual moments where a seller and a buyer finally meet in the middle. Sometimes it’s a price adjustment. Sometimes it’s a seller credit. Sometimes it’s a creative loan program. And sometimes it’s simply time, as incomes rise and old memories fade.
The correction isn’t an event. It’s a conversation. And conversations go a whole lot better with a good translator in the room.
Where Trust Wins
Sellers still want to feel respected for what they built. Buyers still want to feel safe about what they’re taking on. Both of them want someone who will tell them the truth kindly and help them make a good decision.
That’s us.
When you show a seller the buyer’s math with empathy, you build trust. When you show a buyer real options instead of pressure, you build trust. And trust is still the greatest competitive advantage.
What next?
Sit down with your lending or real estate partner and run the payment math together. Put price, concessions, buydowns, and loan programs side by side.
Then have the conversation. Calmly. Clearly. With numbers instead of opinions.
Knowledge is power. Let’s use it to help both sides of the table finally meet.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does “price memory vs. payment reality” mean?
It describes the gap between what sellers expect, based on prices set when borrowing was cheap, and what buyers can afford, based on the monthly payment at today’s higher rates.
Is this gap a sign the housing market is going to crash?
Not necessarily. In most markets the gap closes through many small adjustments: price changes, seller credits, smarter loan structures, and rising incomes over time.
Why do higher rates matter so much if the home price stays the same?
Because buyers budget by the month. On a $350,000 loan, moving from 3% to 6.5% adds roughly $736 a month in principal and interest alone.
How can a realtor help a seller understand today’s buyer?
Show the seller what a typical buyer’s monthly payment looks like at their list price, and how much each extra $25,000 in price adds to that payment.
Is a seller concession better than a price reduction?
Often, yes. Seller credits applied to a rate buydown can lower a buyer’s payment more than the same dollars taken off the price. Your loan officer can run both scenarios side by side.
What is a temporary buydown?
A temporary buydown lowers the buyer’s interest rate for the first year or two of the loan, usually funded by a seller credit, to ease the payment while the buyer settles in.
Can a buyer assume a seller’s existing low-rate loan?
Some FHA and VA loans are assumable. The buyer must qualify and the servicer must approve, and the buyer may need to cover the seller’s equity in cash or with secondary financing.
Should loan officers tell buyers they can refinance later?
Only as a possibility, never as a promise. The safest plan is a payment the buyer can afford today. A future refinance is a bonus if rates cooperate.
How should a realtor and loan officer work together on listings?
Build a simple payment sheet for each listing, review pricing and concession strategy together, and agree on talking points before the listing goes live.
What is the single most important thing to do in this market?
Translate. Help sellers see the buyer’s payment, help buyers see their options, and replace pressure with clear numbers.
Source: Original commentary by Kate Deiboldt, The Deal Doctor. Payment examples are illustrative, principal and interest only, and are not a rate quote or commitment to lend.
Kate Deiboldt, Senior Mortgage Advisor | VanDyk Mortgage Corporation
NMLS #18487 | Company NMLS #3035
Kate@VanDykMortgage.com | (931) 980-9764
www.justcallkate.info | Facebook: @katematties
Licensed in TN, KY, AL, FL, GA, TX, and IL. Equal Housing Lender.

Leave a Reply